Suggestions by @mercury4ever

Chazz Palminteri

as Vincente Minnelli in Not the Boy Next Door

Score: +1

Freddie Fox

as Chris Bell in Not the Boy Next Door

Score: +1

Charlie Carver

as Gregory Connell in Not the Boy Next Door

Score: +1

Logan Lerman

as David Foster in Not the Boy Next Door

Score: +1

Sam Neill

as Frank Sinatra in Not the Boy Next Door

Score: +1

Thomas Gibson

as Mark Herron in Not the Boy Next Door

Score: 0

Kate Winslet

as Judy Garland in Not the Boy Next Door

Score: 0

Anya Taylor-Joy

as Liza Minnelli in Not the Boy Next Door

Score: +1

Liam Hemsworth

as Peter Allen in Not the Boy Next Door

Score: 0

Dexter Fletcher

as Director in Not the Boy Next Door

Score: +1

Peter Krause

as Jeff Ashton in American Crime Story: Casey Anthony

Score: +1

Jake Hoffman

as Jerry Rubin in American Crime Story: The Assassination of John Lennon

Score: +1

Kristin Scott Thomas

as Mimi Smith in American Crime Story: The Assassination of John Lennon

Score: +1

Claire Foy

as Julia Lennon in American Crime Story: The Assassination of John Lennon

Score: +1

John Carroll Lynch

as J. Edgar Hoover in American Crime Story: The Assassination of John Lennon

Score: +2

Tom Felton

as Eric Clapton in American Crime Story: The Assassination of John Lennon

Score: +1

Sam Riley

as Brian Epstein in American Crime Story: The Assassination of John Lennon

Score: 0

Preston Nyman

as John Lennon (Flashback) in American Crime Story: The Assassination of John Lennon

Score: +3

Brad Kavanagh

as Pete Best in American Crime Story: The Assassination of John Lennon

Score: +1

Angus Imrie

as Ringo Starr (Flashback) in American Crime Story: The Assassination of John Lennon

Score: +1