Suggestions by @meowyme

Jeremy Kleckner

as Billy Deep in Goosebumps 3: Slappy Ever After

Score: +4

Rueby Wood

as Billy Deep in Goosebumps 3: Slappy Ever After

Score: -1

Jim Carrey

as Mr Wood in Goosebumps 3: Slappy Ever After

Score: +2

Gemma Brooke Allen

as Terri Sadler in Goosebumps: Ghost Beach Movie

Score: +1

Brecken Merrill

as Jerry Sadler in Goosebumps: Ghost Beach Movie

Score: +1

Jason Maybaum

as Luke Morris in Goosebumps 3: Slappy Ever After

Score: +2

Sara Arjun

as Lizzy Morris in Goosebumps 3: Slappy Ever After

Score: +2

Hannah Riley

as Amanda Benson in Goosebumps 3: Slappy Ever After

Score: +3

Elizabeth Ulrikh

as Nicole Blake in Goosebumps 3: Slappy Ever After

Score: +2

Florence Pugh

as Sarabeth in Goosebumps Monster Blood The Movie

Score: +1

Patrick Stewart

as Store Keeper in Goosebumps Monster Blood The Movie

Score: +1

Glenn Close

as Aunt Kathryn in Goosebumps Monster Blood The Movie

Score: +2

Tantoo Cardinal

as Aunt Kathryn in Goosebumps Monster Blood The Movie

Score: +1

Giulia Benite

as Andrea in Goosebumps Monster Blood The Movie

Score: +2

Bradley Bundlie

as Evan Ross in Goosebumps Monster Blood The Movie

Score: +1

Josh Brolin

as The Menace in Goosebumps 3: Slappy Ever After

Score: +1

James Brolin

as The Menace in Goosebumps 3: Slappy Ever After

Score: +2

Chris Hemsworth

as Byron in Goosebumps 3: Slappy Ever After

Score: +2

Tom Hanks

as Horror #2 in Goosebumps 3: Slappy Ever After

Score: +2

Danny DeVito

as Horror #1 in Goosebumps 3: Slappy Ever After

Score: +2