Suggestions by @mcknee

Gaten Matarazzo

as Jimmy Olsen in Superman: American Alien

Score: +2

Natalia Dyer

as Lois Lane in Superman: American Alien

Score: +2

Leonardo DiCaprio

as Lex Luthor in Superman: American Alien

Score: +3

Vincent D'Onofrio

as Ultra-Humanite in Superman: American Alien

Score: +3

Omari Hardwick

as Atomic Skull in Superman: American Alien

Score: +2

David Corenswet

as Superman in Superman: American Alien

Score: +2

McKnee

as Writer in Batman: Night of the Beast

Score: +1

Jarin Blaschke

as Cinematographer in Batman: Night of the Beast

Score: +1

Tyler Bates

as Composer in Batman: Night of the Beast

Score: +1

Chad Stahelski

as Director in Batman: Night of the Beast

Score: +1

Regina King

as KGBeast’s Savior in Batman: Night of the Beast

Score: +3

Spoiler

as KGBeast’s Savior in Batman: Night of the Beast

Score: +5

Sylvester Stallone

as Ted Grant in Batman: Night of the Beast

Score: +3

Dean Norris

as Commissioner Gillian B. Loeb in Batman: Night of the Beast

Score: +2

Jake Gyllenhaal

as Det. Vic Sage in Batman: Night of the Beast

Score: +4

Alice Braga

as Det. Renee Montoya in Batman: Night of the Beast

Score: +3

Pablo Schreiber

as Det. Arnold Flass in Batman: Night of the Beast

Score: +1

Happy Anderson

as Det. Harvey Bullock in Batman: Night of the Beast

Score: +1

Sadie Sink

as Barbra Gordon in Batman: Night of the Beast

Score: +2

David Harbour

as Det. Jim Gordon in Batman: Night of the Beast

Score: +3