Suggestions by @maxnguyen

Skeet Ulrich

as Jughead Jones in Riverdale (1995)

Score: +2

Reese Witherspoon

as Cheryl Blossom in Riverdale (1995)

Score: +1

Mel Gibson

as Hal Cooper in Riverdale (1995)

Score: +1

Elijah Wood

as Archie Andrews in Riverdale (1995)

Score: +1

Elijah Wood

as Kobra in Mortal Kombat

Score: +1

Kerr Smith

as Johnny Cage in Mortal Kombat

Score: 0

Riley Keough

as Kira in Mortal Kombat

Score: +1

Joshua Jackson

as Det. John Hartigan in Sin City (2021)

Score: +1

Reese Witherspoon

as Shellie in Sin City (2021)

Score: +2

Selma Blair

as Goldie / Wendy in Sin City (2021)

Score: +2

Sean Cw Johnson

as Johnny Cage in Mortal Kombat: The Sub-Zero Chronicles

Score: -1

Leonor Varela

as Ashrah in Mortal Kombat 2

Score: -2

Reese Witherspoon

as Bella Swan in Twilight Saga (1990s Casting)

Score: -1

Molly Ringwald

as Bella Swan in Twilight Saga (1987-1992)

Score: +1

Melanie Lynskey

as Alice Cullen in Twilight Saga (1990s Casting)

Score: +2

Joshua Jackson

as Edward Cullen in Twilight Saga (1990s Casting)

Score: -1

Neve Campbell

as Bella Swan in Twilight (1998-2002)

Score: +2

Freddie Prinze Jr.

as Edward Cullen in Twilight (1998-2002)

Score: 0