Suggestions by @maxmazzotti

Hugh Jackman

as Bruce Wayne in Superman/Batman: Apocalypse (2000)

Score: +1

Henry Cavill

as Superman in Superman/Batman: Public Enemies

Score: +1

Tony Todd

as Uxas in Justice League: Apokolips (2016)

Score: +1

Tony Todd

as Uxas in Justice League: Fight for the future (2014)

Score: +1

Jeffrey Dean Morgan

as Agamemnon in Zack Snyder's The Odyssey

Score: +1

Henry Cavill

as Menelaus in Zack Snyder's The Odyssey

Score: +1

Lena Headey

as Circe in Zack Snyder's The Odyssey

Score: +1

Abbie Cornish

as Athena in Zack Snyder's The Odyssey

Score: +1

Dylan Sprayberry

as Telemachus in Zack Snyder's The Odyssey

Score: +1

Antje Traue

as Penelope in Zack Snyder's The Odyssey

Score: +1

Ben Affleck

as Odysseus in Zack Snyder's The Odyssey

Score: +1

Zack Snyder

as Director in Zack Snyder's The Odyssey

Score: +1

Famke Janssen

as Diana Prince in Justice League: The Final Crisis (2006)

Score: +2

Famke Janssen

as Diana Prince in JL2: Justice League United (2003)

Score: +2

Famke Janssen

as Diana Prince in Justice League (2000)

Score: +2

Sarah Pidgeon

as Diana Prince/Wonder Woman in The Trinity

Score: +1

Elizabeth Debicki

as Diana Prince/Wonder Woman in The Trinity

Score: +1

Oliver Jackson-Cohen

as Bruce Wayne/Batman in The Trinity

Score: +1

David Corenswet

as Clark Kent/Superman in The Trinity

Score: +1

Antje Traue

as Aphrodite in Universal Studios' HADES

Score: +1