Suggestions by @maxlindstedt

Patrick Stewart

as Obi-Wan Kenobi in William Shakespeare’s Star Wars

Score: +1

Ralph Fiennes

as Tarkin in William Shakespeare’s Star Wars

Score: +2

Benedict Cumberbatch

as Darth Vader in William Shakespeare’s Star Wars

Score: +1

Ansel Elgort

as Luke Skywalker in William Shakespeare’s Star Wars

Score: -1

Peter Dinklage

as R2-D2 in William Shakespeare’s Star Wars

Score: +1

Michael Keaton

as Bruce Wayne in Batman Beyond

Score: +1

David Tennant

as Prince Prospero in The Raven

Score: +1

Fozzie Bear

as Inigo in The Muppets Princess Bride

Score: 0

Uncle Deadly

as Vizzini in The Muppets Princess Bride

Score: +2

Fozzy Bear

as Inigo in The Muppets Princess Bride

Score: -1

Gonzo the Great

as Humperdinck in The Muppets Princess Bride

Score: +1

Robin the Frog

as Grandson in The Muppets Princess Bride

Score: +1

Swedish Chef

as Cleric in The Muppets Princess Bride

Score: +1

Beaker

as Valarie in The Muppets Princess Bride

Score: +1

Dr. Bunsen Honeydew

as Miracle Max in The Muppets Princess Bride

Score: +1

Sam the Eagle

as Rugen in The Muppets Princess Bride

Score: +1

Uncle Deadly

as Humperdinck in The Muppets Princess Bride

Score: -1

Sweetums

as Fezzik in The Muppets Princess Bride

Score: +1

Gonzo the Great

as Inigo in The Muppets Princess Bride

Score: 0

Miss Piggy

as Buttercup in The Muppets Princess Bride

Score: +1