Suggestions by @maxlindstedt
490 suggestions
Bill Nighy
as Alfred Pennyworth in Batman: The Long Halloween
Score: 0
Bill Skarsgård
as Scarecrow in Batman: The Long Halloween
Score: 0
Jim Carrey
as The Riddler in Batman: The Long Halloween
Score: +1
Michael Shannon
as Thomas Wayne in Batman: The Long Halloween
Score: +2
Michael Sheen
as Mad Hatter in Batman: The Long Halloween
Score: +1
Jane Levy
as Poison Ivy in Batman: The Long Halloween
Score: 0
David Tennant
as Joker in Batman: The Long Halloween
Score: 0
David Harbour
as James Gordon in Batman: The Long Halloween
Score: 0
Jennifer Lawrence
as Catwoman in Batman: The Long Halloween
Score: -1
John Carroll Lynch
as Penguin in Batman: The Long Halloween
Score: +1
Mads Mikkelsen
as Calendar Man in Batman: The Long Halloween
Score: +2
Tom Hiddleston
as Salvatore Maroni in Batman: The Long Halloween
Score: +1
Josh Brolin
as Carmine Falcone in Batman: The Long Halloween
Score: +2
Robert Downey Jr.
as Carmine Falcone in Batman: The Long Halloween
Score: +2
Jeffrey Dean Morgan
as Carmine Falcone in Batman: The Long Halloween
Score: +1
Dave Bautista
as Solomon Grundy in Batman: The Long Halloween
Score: +1
Armie Hammer
as Bruce Wayne/Batman in Batman: The Long Halloween
Score: 0
Deborah Ann Woll
as Player 6 in Celebrity Dungeons and Dragons
Score: +4
Mila Kunis
as Player 5 in Celebrity Dungeons and Dragons
Score: 0
Felicia Day
as Player 4 in Celebrity Dungeons and Dragons
Score: +2