Suggestions by @maxclaire

Abigail Cowen

as Carrie White in Horror Queens Recast

Score: +5

Abigail Cowen

as Ginger Fitzgerald in Horror Queens Recast

Score: +3

Mckenna Grace

as Esther in Horror Queens Recast

Score: +3

Alexa Demie

as Jennifer Check in Horror Queens Recast

Score: +8

Ralph Macchio

as Will Byers in Stranger Things (1980s)

Score: +2

Phoebe Cates

as Nancy Wheeler in Stranger Things (1980s)

Score: 0

Heather Locklear

as Angela in Stranger Things (1980s)

Score: +1

Molly Ringwald

as Max Hagrove in Stranger Things (1980s)

Score: +3

Uma Thurman

as Robin Buckley in Stranger Things (1980s)

Score: +3

Jenny Lewis

as Max Hagrove in Stranger Things (1980s)

Score: +2

Felissa Rose

as Eleven in Stranger Things (1980s)

Score: +1

Jonathan Taylor Thomas

as Mike Wheeler in Stranger Things (1994~2004)

Score: +2

Macaulay Culkin

as Will Byers in Stranger Things (1994~2004)

Score: +2

Edward Furlong

as Will Byers in Stranger Things (1994~2004)

Score: +2

Tatyana Ali

as Erica Sinclair in Stranger Things (1994~2004)

Score: +4

Jaleel White

as Lucas Sinclair in Stranger Things (1994~2004)

Score: +2

Jamie Lee Curtis

as Joyce Byers in Stranger Things (1994~2004)

Score: +2

Drew Barrymore

as Robin Buckley in Stranger Things (1994~2004)

Score: +3

Uma Thurman

as Robin Buckley in Stranger Things (1994~2004)

Score: +3

Rachel McAdams

as Angela in Stranger Things (1994~2004)

Score: +3