Suggestions by @maxclaire

Madelaine Petsch

as Daphne Blake in Redhead Girls Recast

Score: +4

Mariel Hemingway

as Bella Hartley in H2O: Just add Water (1986-1990)

Score: +7

Sadie Sink

as Starfire in Redhead Girls Recast

Score: +4

Vivian Watson

as Max Mayfield in Redhead Girls Recast

Score: +3

Sadie Sink

as Bloom Peters in Redhead Girls Recast

Score: +4

Sadie Sink

as Rose DeWitt BukKater in Redhead Girls Recast

Score: +5

Sadie Sink

as Cady Heron in Redhead Girls Recast

Score: +3

Abigail Cowen

as Ariel in Redhead Girls Recast

Score: +5

Shay Rudolph

as Aquamarine in Blonde Girls Recast

Score: +3

Samara Weaving

as Chanel Oberlin in Blonde Girls Recast

Score: +4

Elle Fanning

as Luna Lovegood in Blonde Girls Recast

Score: +4

Sydney Sweeney

as Karen Smith in Blonde Girls Recast

Score: +3

Emma Roberts

as Regina George in Blonde Girls Recast

Score: +7

Elodie Grace Orkin

as Regina George in Blonde Girls Recast

Score: +6

Sydney Sweeney

as Elle Woods in Blonde Girls Recast

Score: +3

Alicia Silverstone

as Elle Woods in What Characters Do You Want to See Alicia Silverstone Play in the '90s

Score: +4

Elle Fanning

as Ashley Graham in Horror Queens Recast

Score: +2

Thomasin McKenzie

as Nancy thompson in Horror Queens Recast

Score: +3

Julia Voth

as Jill Valentine in Horror Queens Recast

Score: +2

Teagan Croft

as Claire Benoit in Horror Queens Recast

Score: +3