Suggestions by @maxclaire

Finn Wolfhard

as The Goth/Emo in The Perfect Prom Movie

Score: +4

Jenna Ortega

as The Goth/Emo in The Perfect Prom Movie

Score: +4

Ben Whishaw

as Random LGBT School Staff Member in The Perfect Prom Movie

Score: +3

Wednesday Addams (2022)

as 2020s in Teen TV characters by Decade

Score: +9

Daisy Edgar-Jones

as Vivian Kensington in Legally Blonde (2024)

Score: +4

Sydney Sweeney

as Elle Woods in Legally Blonde (2024)

Score: +4

Amy Adams

as 2000s in Which Actress Should've Played Ginger Fitzgerald in Various Decades?

Score: +5

Reneé Rapp

as 2020s in What Actresses Could've Played Cassie Howard in Various Decades?

Score: +4

Cassie Howard

as Alicia Silverstone in Which Characters Actors And Actresses Should Have Played In The 90s ?

Score: +4

Barbie (Live-Action)

as Alicia Silverstone in Which Characters Actors And Actresses Should Have Played In The 90s ?

Score: +4

Betty Cooper (Riverdale)

as Brittany Murphy in Which Characters Actors And Actresses Should Have Played In The 90s ?

Score: +3

Lisa Swallows

as Reese Witherspoon in Which Characters Actors And Actresses Should Have Played In The 90s ?

Score: +3

Sue Snell (2013)

as Reese Witherspoon in Which Characters Actors And Actresses Should Have Played In The 90s ?

Score: +4

Regina George

as Alicia Silverstone in Which Characters Actors And Actresses Should Have Played In The 90s ?

Score: +4

Karen Smith

as Alicia Silverstone in Which Characters Actors And Actresses Should Have Played In The 90s ?

Score: +3

Elle Woods

as Alicia Silverstone in Which Characters Actors And Actresses Should Have Played In The 90s ?

Score: +3

Devon Aoki

as Yoko Tanaka in Wednesday (1997)

Score: +4

Amanda Seyfried

as Rapunzel in What Characters Do You Want to See Amanda Seyfried Play in the 2000s

Score: +4

Carrie (1976 film)

as Maxclaire in Your Favorite Movies from before you were born

Score: +5

Heathers

as Maxclaire in Your Favorite Movies from before you were born

Score: +4