Suggestions by @maxclaire

Maya Hawke

as Mia Wallace in If 1990s characters rebooted nowadays

Score: +3

Linda Cardellini

as Gretchen Wieners in Mean Girls (1993)

Score: +3

Sarah Michelle Gellar

as Regina George in Mean Girls (1993)

Score: +2

Selma Blair

as Gretchen Wieners in Mean Girls (1993)

Score: +2

Linda Cardellini

as Gretchen Wieners in Mean Girls (1993)

Score: +2

Leonardo DiCaprio

as Aaron Samuels in Mean Girls (1993)

Score: +4

John Stamos

as Aaron Samuels in Mean Girls (1993)

Score: +1

Ryan Phillippe

as Aaron Samuels in Mean Girls (1993)

Score: +3

Brendan Fraser

as Damian in Mean Girls (1993)

Score: +3

Isla Fisher

as Cady Heron in Mean Girls (1993)

Score: +3

Juliette Lewis

as Janis Ian in Mean Girls (1993)

Score: +4

Alicia Silverstone

as Karen Smith in Mean Girls (1993)

Score: +4

Christine Taylor

as Regina George in Mean Girls (1993)

Score: +4

Christina Applegate

as Regina George in Mean Girls (1993)

Score: +7

Asher Angel

as School Athletes in Obsession

Score: +1

Mckenna Grace

as Madeline in Obsession

Score: +1

Dafne Keen

as Amber in Obsession

Score: 0

Millie Bobby Brown

as Amber in Obsession

Score: +2

Jenna Ortega

as Amber in Obsession

Score: 0

Elodie Grace Orkin

as Sienna in Obsession

Score: +3