Suggestions by @maxcarter

James Stewart

as Heaven's Light in The Hunchback of Norte Dame (1946)

Score: +4

Katharine Hepburn

as God Help the Outcasts in The Hunchback of Norte Dame (1946)

Score: +4

Gary Cooper

as Topsy Turvy in The Hunchback of Norte Dame (1946)

Score: +4

Paul Robeson

as The Bells of Notre Dame in The Hunchback of Norte Dame (1946)

Score: +4

Fay Wray

as Vaggie in Hazbin Hotel (1939 Pilot verison)

Score: 0

Boris Karloff

as Finale sung by in Hazbin Hotel (1944)

Score: +4

Claude Rains

as Finale sung by in Hazbin Hotel (1944)

Score: +4

Judith Anderson

as Finale sung by in Hazbin Hotel (1944)

Score: -2

Claudette Colbert

as Finale sung by in Hazbin Hotel (1944)

Score: +4

Paul Robeson

as Finale sung by in Hazbin Hotel (1944)

Score: +4

William Haines

as Finale sung by in Hazbin Hotel (1944)

Score: +4

Bela Lugosi

as Finale sung by in Hazbin Hotel (1944)

Score: +4

Marilyn Monroe

as Finale sung by in Hazbin Hotel (1944)

Score: +4

Cary Grant

as Finale sung by in Hazbin Hotel (1944)

Score: +4

Judy Garland

as Finale sung by in Hazbin Hotel (1944)

Score: +4

Judy Garland and Marilyn Monroe

as More Than Anything (Reprise) sung by in Hazbin Hotel (1944)

Score: +4

Conrad Veidt

as You Didn't Know sung by in Hazbin Hotel (1944)

Score: +4

Lucille Ball

as You Didn't Know sung by in Hazbin Hotel (1944)

Score: +4

Marilyn Monroe

as You Didn't Know sung by in Hazbin Hotel (1944)

Score: +4

Judy Garland

as You Didn't Know sung by in Hazbin Hotel (1944)

Score: +4