Suggestions by @max23

Charlie Hunnam

as Siegfried Schtauffen in Soulcalibur(story removed)

Score: 0

Jeremy Irons

as Cervantes de Leon in Soulcalibur(story removed)

Score: +2

Willem Dafoe

as Kyosuke Higuchi in Death Note(story removed)

Score: -1

Kevin Bacon

as Kyosuke Higuchi in Death Note(story removed)

Score: +5

Aaron Eckhart

as Aiber in Death Note(story removed)

Score: +7

Robbie Amell

as Stephen Gevanni in Death Note(story removed)

Score: +2

Tao Okamoto

as Naomi Misora in Death Note(story removed)

Score: -4

Brandon Routh

as Ray Penbar in Death Note(story removed)

Score: +1

Grant Gustin

as Light Yagami in Death Note(story removed)

Score: -8

Dakota Fanning

as Misa Amane in Death Note(story removed)

Score: -6

Mary Elizabeth Winstead

as Kyomi Takada in Death Note(story removed)

Score: -2

Christopher Plummer

as Watari in Death Note(story removed)

Score: 0

Tom Selleck

as Soichiro Yagami in Death Note(story removed)

Score: +10

Bryan Cranston

as Soichiro Yagami in Death Note(story removed)

Score: +4

Christopher Nolan

as Director in Death Note(story removed)

Score: 0

Saoirse Ronan

as Misa Amane in Death Note(story removed)

Score: -13

Amanda Seyfried

as Misa Amane in Death Note(story removed)

Score: -7

Lucas Till

as Light Yagami in Death Note(story removed)

Score: -14

Chace Crawford

as Light Yagami in Death Note(story removed)

Score: -11

Ezra Miller

as L. Lawliet in Death Note(story removed)

Score: -9