Suggestions by @matthewthefox1999

Andrew Garfield

as Phone Guy (Scott Franklin) in Five Nights At Freddy's: A Shattered Awakening (Remake)

Score: +2

Joe Keery

as Michael Afton / Springtrap / Mike Schmidt in Five Nights At Freddy's: A Shattered Awakening (Remake)

Score: +1

Daniel Pemberton

as Composer in Undertale: The Animated Series

Score: +1

Francisco Angones

as Writer in Undertale: The Animated Series

Score: +1

Michael Waldron

as Writer in Undertale: The Animated Series

Score: -1

Toby Fox

as Director in Undertale: The Animated Series

Score: +1

Guillermo del Toro

as Director in Undertale: The Animated Series

Score: +1

LaKeith Stanfield

as Montgomery Gator in Five Nights At Freddy's: A Shattered Awakening (Remake)

Score: +1

Henry Jackman

as Composer in Five Nights At Freddy's: A Shattered Awakening (Remake)

Score: +1

Barry Keoghan

as Flowey in Undertale: The Animated Series

Score: +2

Timothée Chalamet

as Napstablook in Undertale: The Animated Series

Score: +2

Idris Elba

as Asgore in Undertale: The Animated Series

Score: +2

Odeya Rush

as Stone The Crow in Five Nights At Freddy's: A Shattered Awakening (Remake)

Score: +2

Steve Agee

as Pigpatch in Fazbear's Glamrock Family

Score: +1

Paul F. Tompkins

as Rockstar Freddy in Five Nights At Freddy's: A Shattered Awakening (Remake)

Score: +1

Kate Micucci

as Alphys in Undertale: The Animated Series

Score: +1

Pom Klementieff

as Guest Stars in Undertale: The Animated Series

Score: +1

Pete Davidson

as Guest Stars in Undertale: The Animated Series

Score: +1

Flula Borg

as Guest Stars in Undertale: The Animated Series

Score: +1

Jennifer Holland

as Guest Stars in Undertale: The Animated Series

Score: +1