Suggestions by @matthewsummerford
104 suggestions
Elizabeth Olsen
as Kate Brewster in Terminator: Requiem
Score: +1
Robert Patrick
as Colonel Robert Brewster in Terminator: Requiem
Score: +1
Arnold Schwarzenegger
as William Candy in Terminator: Requiem
Score: +1
Linda Hamilton
as Sarah Conner in Terminator: Requiem
Score: +1
Edward Furlong
as John Conner in Terminator: Requiem
Score: +1
John Cena
as Mike Haggar in Final Fight
Score: 0
Dylan Minnette
as The Geek in Friday the 13th: Sequel/Reboot Trilogy
Score: +1
Evan Peters
as The Prankster in Friday the 13th: Sequel/Reboot Trilogy
Score: +1
Paul Rudd
as Camp's Owner in Friday the 13th: Sequel/Reboot Trilogy
Score: +1
Nathan Jones
as Jason Voorhees in Friday the 13th: Sequel/Reboot Trilogy
Score: +1
Michael Rooker
as Grandpa Sawyer in The Texas Chainsaw Massacre (Horror Cinematic Universe)(story removed)
Score: +2
Woody Harrelson
as Drayton Sawyer in The Texas Chainsaw Massacre (Horror Cinematic Universe)(story removed)
Score: +1
Walton Goggins
as Chop Top in The Texas Chainsaw Massacre (Horror Cinematic Universe)(story removed)
Score: +1
Walton Goggins
as Hitchiker in The Texas Chainsaw Massacre (Horror Cinematic Universe)(story removed)
Score: +1
David Harbour
as Leatherface in The Texas Chainsaw Massacre (Horror Cinematic Universe)(story removed)
Score: +2
Ethan Hawke
as Dr. Sam Loomis in Halloween (Horror Cinematic Universe)
Score: +1
Oscar Isaac
as Ash Williams in Hellraiser (Horror Cinematic Universe)
Score: 0
Ewan McGregor
as Pinhead in Hellraiser (Horror Cinematic Universe)
Score: 0
Kevin Bacon
as Freddy Krueger in A Nightmare On Elm Street (Horror Cinematic Universe)
Score: +2
Kevin Costner
as Freddy Krueger in A Nightmare On Elm Street (Horror Cinematic Universe)
Score: -1