Suggestions by @mattcartelli

Ryan Gosling

as Walt Disney (Young) in If You Can Dream It

Score: +1

Ryan Gosling

as Walt Disney (Old) in If You Can Dream It

Score: +1

Tom Hanks

as Walt Disney (Young) in If You Can Dream It

Score: +1

Seth Rogen

as Alan menken in Howard

Score: +1

Rodrigo Santoro

as Licenciado Piña in Zorro (Disney Plus Remake)

Score: 0

Javier Bardem

as Don Ignacio Torres in Zorro (Disney Plus Remake)

Score: +3

Edward James Olmos

as Magistrate Carlos Galindo in Zorro (Disney Plus Remake)

Score: +2

Jaime Camil

as Captain Enrique Sánchez Monastario in Zorro (Disney Plus Remake)

Score: -4

Pedro Pascal

as Carlos Martinez in Zorro (Disney Plus Remake)

Score: +1

Carlos Martínez

as Bernardo in Zorro (Disney Plus Remake)

Score: +1

Benedict Cumberbatch

as Captain Enrique Sánchez Monastario in Zorro (Disney Plus Remake)

Score: -1

Leslie Grace

as Elena Torres in Zorro (Disney Plus Remake)

Score: +2

Benicio del Toro

as José Sebastián de Varga in Zorro (Disney Plus Remake)

Score: +2

Antonio Banderas

as Don Alejandro De la Vega in Zorro (Disney Plus Remake)

Score: +5

Héctor Elizondo

as Padre Felipe in Zorro (Disney Plus Remake)

Score: +3

Michael Peña

as Corporal Reyes in Zorro (Disney Plus Remake)

Score: +3

John Leguizamo

as Corporal Reyes in Zorro (Disney Plus Remake)

Score: +4

Gabriel Iglesias

as Sergeant Demetrio Lopez Garcia in Zorro (Disney Plus Remake)

Score: +1

Wilmer Valderrama

as Don Diego De la Vega in Zorro (Disney Plus Remake)

Score: -3

Alan Dale

as Frollo in The Hunchback of Notre Dame

Score: -7