Suggestions by @masterofcool

Ron Perlman

as Mongul in Green Lantern Corps II: Warworld (1996)

Score: +3

Denis Leary

as Green Lantern III in Green Lantern Corps II: Warworld (1996)

Score: +3

Carl Weathers

as Green Lantern II in Green Lantern Corps II: Warworld (1996)

Score: +3

Bruce Willis

as Green Lantern I in Green Lantern Corps II: Warworld (1996)

Score: +4

Tony Scott

as Director in Green Lantern Corps II: Warworld (1996)

Score: +3

Graeme Revell

as Composer in The Sandman (1996)

Score: +2

Jonathan Pryce

as Lucien in The Sandman (1996)

Score: +4

Tom Noonan

as Doctor Destiny in The Sandman (1996)

Score: +4

Universal Pictures

as Production Company in The Sandman (1996)

Score: +2

Tim Roth

as John Constantine in The Sandman (1996)

Score: +5

Lena Olin

as Desire in The Sandman (1996)

Score: +3

Tim Curry

as Hob Gadling in The Sandman (1996)

Score: +4

John Goodman

as Abel in The Sandman (1996)

Score: +4

Vincent Schiavelli

as Cain in The Sandman (1996)

Score: +4

Peter Boyle

as Merv Pumpkinhead in The Sandman (1996)

Score: +3

James Woods

as Matthew The Raven in The Sandman (1996)

Score: +5

David Bowie

as Lucifer Morningstar in The Sandman (1996)

Score: +4

Paul McGann

as Alex Burgess in The Sandman (1996)

Score: +3

Patrick McGoohan

as Roderick Burgess in The Sandman (1996)

Score: +4

Woody Harrelson

as The Corinthian in The Sandman (1996)

Score: +5