Suggestions by @marvelforever

Lily Tucker-Pritchett

as July in Annie If Fictional Characters Made It

Score: +1

Amy Poehler

as Mrs. Mayor in If Disney Did Seussical!

Score: +1

Emily Blunt

as Mayzie La Bird in If Disney Did Seussical!

Score: +1

Maddie Ziegler

as Z in The ABCs Of Best Actresses

Score: +2

Erika Henningsen

as H in The ABCs Of Best Actresses

Score: +1

Ms. Norbury

as Grace in Annie If Fictional Characters Made It

Score: +3

Kate Rockwell

as Bebe Stevens in South Park: Bigger Longer And Uncut Broadway

Score: +1

Michael James Scott

as Chef in South Park: Bigger Longer And Uncut Broadway

Score: +1

Ryan McCartan

as Eric Cartman in South Park: Bigger Longer And Uncut Broadway

Score: +1

Sierra Boggess

as Sharon Marsh in South Park: Bigger Longer And Uncut Broadway

Score: +1

Beth Leavel

as Shelia Broflovski in South Park: Bigger Longer And Uncut Broadway

Score: +1

Kerry Butler

as Liane Cartman in South Park: Bigger Longer And Uncut Broadway

Score: +1

Ashley Park

as Wendy Testaburger in South Park: Bigger Longer And Uncut Broadway

Score: +1

Ethan Slater

as Kyle Broflovski in South Park: Bigger Longer And Uncut Broadway

Score: +1

Grey Henson

as Stan Marsh in South Park: Bigger Longer And Uncut Broadway

Score: +1

Vaggie (Hazbin Hotel)

as Pepper in Annie If Fictional Characters Made It

Score: +1

Janis Ian

as Pepper in Annie If Fictional Characters Made It

Score: +1

Annie James

as Annie in Annie If Fictional Characters Made It

Score: +2

Jessica Rabbit

as Star to Be in Annie If Fictional Characters Made It

Score: +1

Wadsworth (Clue)

as Rooster in Annie If Fictional Characters Made It

Score: +1