Suggestions by @martinandrew

Spencer Breslin

as Jock Moffat in The Rhine Exercise

Score: +1

Wendi McLendon-Covey

as Patti Nielson in The Columbine Massacre: American Crime Story

Score: +2

Vince Vaughn

as Lt. Charles Warren in The Skies of September

Score: +1

Ralph Fiennes

as Judge Claude Frollo in Hunchback of Notre Dame

Score: +1

Patrick Warburton

as Andrew Thomason in The Skies of September

Score: +1

Dennis Quaid

as Andrew Thomason in The Skies of September

Score: -1

Dennis Quaid

as Nick Morris in The Skies of September

Score: +1

Tom Selleck

as Nick Morris in The Skies of September

Score: +1

Dennis Quaid

as Nick Morris in The Skies of September

Score: +1

Patrick Warburton

as Andrew Thomason in The Skies of September

Score: +1

Steve Guttenberg

as Andrew Thomason in The Skies of September

Score: -1

Dennis Quaid

as Andrew Thomason in The Skies of September

Score: +1

Mark Wahlberg

as Lt. Charles Warren in The Skies of September

Score: +1

Neal McDonough

as Lt. Charles Warren in The Skies of September

Score: +1

William Franklyn-Miller

as Mohammed Atta in The Skies of September

Score: +1

Glenn McMillan

as Mohammed Atta in The Skies of September

Score: +1

Mark Wahlberg

as Lt. Charles Warren in The Skies of September

Score: +1

Neal McDonough

as Lt. Charles Warren in The Skies of September

Score: +1

Derek Mears

as Melanie in The Skies of September

Score: -1

Sam Elliott

as Nick Morris in The Skies of September

Score: -1