Suggestions by @marian

Zoe Colletti

as Anastasia in Cinderella

Score: -1

Jill Hennessy

as Lady Tremaine in Cinderella

Score: -1

Kristin Bauer

as Fairy Godmother in Cinderella

Score: -2

Kevin Bacon

as Cinderella's Father in Cinderella

Score: -4

Kristin Bauer

as Lady Tremaine in Cinderella

Score: -1

Dove Cameron

as Anastasia in Cinderella

Score: -1

Agnes Bruckner

as Drizella in Cinderella

Score: -1

Rebecca Mader

as Lady Tremaine in Cinderella

Score: 0

Greg Germann

as Cinderella's Father in Cinderella

Score: +2

Callum Blue

as Beast in Disney Princesses

Score: +2

Hugh Dancy

as Bruce Banner in The Fantastic Four

Score: +3

Caroline Dhavernas

as Sue Storm in The Fantastic Four

Score: -4

Mads Mikkelsen

as Reed Richards in The Fantastic Four

Score: -23

Kat Graham

as Anastasia in Cinderella

Score: -1

Shay Mitchell

as Drizella in Cinderella

Score: -1

Mads Mikkelsen

as Lucifer in Gaiman's Sandman

Score: +1

Katharine Isabelle

as Lady Tremaine in Cinderella

Score: -2

Caroline Dhavernas

as Lady Tremaine in Cinderella

Score: -2

January Jones

as Fairy Godmother in Cinderella

Score: 0

Janet Montgomery

as Drizella in Cinderella

Score: -1