Suggestions by @mangold

Naomi Scott

as Cathrine Marks in The Hathaways

Score: +3

Anju Kurian

as Cathrine Marks in The Hathaways

Score: +1

India Eisley

as Cathrine Marks in The Hathaways

Score: -1

Hande Erçel

as Cathrine Marks in The Hathaways

Score: +4

Adria Arjona

as Cathrine Marks in The Hathaways

Score: +2

Jessica Henwick

as Cathrine Marks in The Hathaways

Score: +7

Şükrü Özyıldız

as Kev Merripen in The Hathaways

Score: +2

Şükrü Özyıldız

as Captain Christopher Phelan in The Hathaways

Score: +1

Adam Pålsson

as Captain Christopher Phelan in The Hathaways

Score: +1

Kerem Bürsin

as Captain Christopher Phelan in The Hathaways

Score: +1

Tom Felton

as Captain Christopher Phelan in The Hathaways

Score: +1

Aaron Taylor-Johnson

as Captain Christopher Phelan in The Hathaways

Score: +3

LaKeith Stanfield

as Captain Christopher Phelan in The Hathaways

Score: +1

Klara Castanho

as Beatrix Hathaway in The Hathaways

Score: +2

Amybeth McNulty

as Beatrix Hathaway in The Hathaways

Score: +10

Izabela Vidovic

as Beatrix Hathaway in The Hathaways

Score: -1

Emilia Jones

as Beatrix Hathaway in The Hathaways

Score: +2

Isabela Merced

as Beatrix Hathaway in The Hathaways

Score: -1

Daniel Radcliffe

as Leo Hathaway/Lord Ramsay in The Hathaways

Score: +2

Grant Gustin

as Leo Hathaway/Lord Ramsay in The Hathaways

Score: 0