Suggestions by @maggiedonaldson

Penn Badgley

as Elliot in The Fury

Score: +2

Ki Hong Lee

as Ethan in Here One Moment

Score: +1

Emilia Clarke

as Paula in Here One Moment

Score: -1

Oscar Isaac

as Leo in Here One Moment

Score: +6

Annette Bening

as Sue in Here One Moment

Score: +6

Ritu Arya

as Allegra in Here One Moment

Score: +1

Daisy Edgar-Jones

as Eve in Here One Moment

Score: +3

Meryl Streep

as Cherry in Here One Moment

Score: +6