Suggestions by @madiburger

Gabi Butler

as Oraya in The Serpent and the Wings of Night

Score: +3

Hannah Dodd

as Anya in Servant of Earth

Score: +1

Bill Skarsgård

as King Osric in Servant of Earth

Score: +1

Mikey Madison

as Lara in Servant of Earth

Score: +1

Josh Heuston

as Rodrick Myndacious in The Knight and the Moth

Score: +1

KJ Apa

as Drustan in Servant of Earth

Score: +2

Matthew Daddario

as Kallen in Servant of Earth

Score: +1

Sadie Sink

as Rune Winters in Heartless Hunter

Score: +2

Jacob Elordi

as Gideon Sharpe in Heartless Hunter

Score: 0

Olivia Rodrigo

as Jude Duarte in Cruel Prince/Folk of the Air Trilogy

Score: +1

Emily Bader

as Kenna in Servant of Earth

Score: +2

Lily James

as Ione in One Dark Window

Score: +2

Elaine Cassidy

as Josie in None of This is True

Score: 0

Selena Gomez

as Briana in Yours Truly

Score: -7

Leo Woodall

as Jacob in Yours Truly

Score: -7