Suggestions by @m_doom1234

Keanu Reeves

as Shadow the hedgehog in Expendables (Video Game Heroes)

Score: +1

Chris Redfield

as What If Smash Bros Had Mature Game Characters? in myFiction

Score: +1

Warwick Davis

as What If Jim Henson directed Super Mario Bros (1993)? in myFiction

Score: +3

Tim Allen

as What If Jim Henson directed Super Mario Bros (1993)? in myFiction

Score: +3

Danny DeVito

as What If Jim Henson directed Super Mario Bros (1993)? in myFiction

Score: +3

Jim Hawkins (Treasure Planet)

as Usagi Tsukino in Crossover Shipping

Score: +2

Cameron Monaghan

as Jeff the Killer in Creepypasta Casting Call

Score: +2

Special infected

as Our Zombies are Different in Sort by Tropes

Score: +2

Demoman

as What If Smash Bros Had Mature Game Characters? in myFiction

Score: +2

Soldier

as What If Smash Bros Had Mature Game Characters? in myFiction

Score: +2

Scout

as What If Smash Bros Had Mature Game Characters? in myFiction

Score: +2

The Pyro

as What If Smash Bros Had Mature Game Characters? in myFiction

Score: +2

Conker the Squirrel

as What If Smash Bros Had Mature Game Characters? in myFiction

Score: +2

Big Daddy

as What If Smash Bros Had Mature Game Characters? in myFiction

Score: +2

Tracer

as What If Smash Bros Had Mature Game Characters? in myFiction

Score: +2

Niko Bellic

as What If Smash Bros Had Mature Game Characters? in myFiction

Score: +2

William J. Blazkowicz

as What If Smash Bros Had Mature Game Characters? in myFiction

Score: +2

Doomguy

as What If Smash Bros Had Mature Game Characters? in myFiction

Score: +2

Dante (Devil May Cry)

as What If Smash Bros Had Mature Game Characters? in myFiction

Score: +2

Leon Kennedy

as What If Smash Bros Had Mature Game Characters? in myFiction

Score: +2