Suggestions by @m3nzies

Allegra Acosta

as Piper in The Next Step

Score: +1

Akira Akbar

as Kenzie in The Next Step

Score: +1

Patrick Page

as Hades in Hadestown (Live-Action)

Score: +8

Amber Grey

as Persephone in Hadestown (Live-Action)

Score: +5

Andy Mientus

as Charley Kringas in Merrily We Roll Along

Score: +3

Raúl Esparza

as Charley Kringas in Merrily We Roll Along

Score: +1

Haskiri Velazquez

as Courtney in Total Drama Island

Score: +1

Annalise Basso

as Izzy in Total Drama Island

Score: +1

Raúl Esparza

as James Hopper in Stranger Things (recast/fancast)

Score: +1

Igby Rigney

as Marty Mcfly in Back to the Future Remake

Score: 0

Katie Douglas

as Maxine Mayfield in Stranger Things (recast/fancast)

Score: +1

Rudy Pankow

as Steve Harrington in Stranger Things (recast/fancast)

Score: +1

Finn Roberts

as Steve Harrington in Stranger Things (recast/fancast)

Score: +1

Lucas Hedges

as Jonathan Byers in Stranger Things (recast/fancast)

Score: +1

Mike Faist

as Jonathan Byers in Stranger Things (recast/fancast)

Score: +1

Ray Nicholson

as William Hargrove in Stranger Things (recast/fancast)

Score: +1

Isis Hainsworth

as Nancy Wheeler in Stranger Things (recast/fancast)

Score: +1

Tripp Bowers

as Trent in Total Drama Island

Score: +1

Maddie Baillio

as Sadie in Total Drama Island

Score: +1

Julia Lester

as Beth in Total Drama Island

Score: +1