Suggestions by @luluf

Giovanna Alparone

as Morrigan in Nevermoor

Score: 0

Madeleine McGraw

as Morrigan in Nevermoor

Score: -2

Matthew Fox

as Ezra Squall in Nevermoor

Score: +1

Seth Green

as Jupiter in Nevermoor

Score: +2

Robert Pattinson

as Jupiter North in Nevermoor

Score: -11

James McAvoy

as Jupiter North in Nevermoor

Score: -7

Jude Law

as Jupiter in Nevermoor

Score: -2

Angel Blue

as Chanda Kali in Nevermoor

Score: +4

Armie Hammer

as Jupiter North in Nevermoor

Score: -9

Asher Angel

as John "Jack" Arjuna Korrapati in Nevermoor

Score: +3

Johnny Depp

as Frank in Nevermoor

Score: -6

Maya Rudolph

as Fenestra/Fen in Nevermoor

Score: 0

Angel Blue

as Chanda Kali in Nevermoor

Score: +5

Ryan Reynolds

as Ezra Squall in Nevermoor

Score: -11

Tom Hiddleston

as Jupiter North in Nevermoor

Score: -4