Suggestions by @lukerogers

Iain Batchelor

as Vance Ritter in The Calhoun's

Score: +1

William H. Macy

as Norman Marshall in The Calhoun's

Score: +1

Lucius Baston

as Dean Gibson in The Calhoun's

Score: +1

Jeff Sprauve

as Glenn Daniels in Stranger things (My way.)

Score: +2

Corbin Allred

as Agent Carloin in Stranger things (My way.)

Score: +2

Isla Fisher

as Vicki Vale in Hush

Score: +1

Dan Triandiflou

as Dr. Jerry Anderson in The Last of Us Fancast

Score: +2

Randy Havens

as Mr. Clarke in Stranger things (My way.)

Score: +2

Tobias Jelinek

as Brett Skinner in Hush

Score: +2

Stefanie Butler

as Cynthia in Stranger things (My way.)

Score: +1

Tobias Jelinek

as Agent Skinner in Stranger things (My way.)

Score: +1

Corbin Allred

as Agent Carver in Stranger things (My way.)

Score: +1

A Newcomer

as Beau in Stranger things (My way.)

Score: +1

Mark Williams

as Father Graham in Man-Bat

Score: 0

Stephen Root

as Father Graham in Man-Bat

Score: +2

John Reynolds

as Man-Bat in Batman

Score: +2

Alec Utgoff

as Dr. Aaron Matthews in Man-Bat

Score: +2

Richard Schiff

as Abraham Langstrom in Man-Bat

Score: +2

Brett Gelman

as Officer Reid in Man-Bat

Score: +2

Phoebe Waller-Bridge

as Jessie Bathe in Man-Bat

Score: +2