Suggestions by @luispoblete

Evan Peters

as The Joker in Batman Film Series

Score: +2

Lee Evans

as Jimmy Valmer in South Park Post Covid

Score: 0

Gerard Butler

as Philionel El Di Saillune in The Slayers

Score: +3

Jackson Robert Scott

as Hellmaster Fibrizo in The Slayers

Score: +2

Jason Momoa

as Chaos Dragon Garv in The Slayers

Score: +2

Robert Pattinson

as Valgarv in The Slayers

Score: +1

Jared Leto

as Rezo in The Slayers

Score: +3

Barney Harris

as Zangulus in The Slayers

Score: +2

Sophia Lillis

as Martina Zoana Mel Navratilova in The Slayers

Score: +3

Sophie Turner

as Sylphiel Nels Lahda in The Slayers

Score: -1

Angourie Rice

as Filia Ul Copt in The Slayers

Score: +2

Noah Schnapp

as Xelloss in The Slayers

Score: +3

Finn Wolfhard

as Xelloss in The Slayers

Score: 0

Sterling Jerins

as Ameria Wil Tesla Seiruum in The Slayers

Score: +2

Timothée Chalamet

as Zelgadiss Graywords in The Slayers

Score: +4

Garrett Hedlund

as Gaudy Gabriev in The Slayers

Score: +3

Jamie Campbell Bower

as Gaudy Gabriev in The Slayers

Score: -2

Sadie Sink

as Lina Inverse in The Slayers

Score: +3

Steven Bauer

as Vicente De Santa in Red Dead Redemption.

Score: +4

Noah Schnapp

as Xelloss in The Slayers

Score: +3