Suggestions by @lucashollan

Judah Lewis

as Jeffery Woods in Jeff The Killer

Score: +2

Rory Culkin

as Øystein Aarseth/Euronymous in Freezing Moon: The Story Of Mayhem: Episode 8: Goodbye Euronymous

Score: +1

Ernie Hudson

as Capt. Hook in The Crow

Score: +3

Judah Lewis

as Jeff the Killer in Jeff The Killer

Score: +1

Michelle Trachtenberg

as Jeff The Killer in Jeff The Killer (Late 2000’s)

Score: -1

Judah Lewis

as Jeff The Killer in Jeff The Killer (Late 2000’s)

Score: +1