Suggestions by @lucasbauman

Liev Schreiber

as Rhino in Spider-verse 3: Reborn (MCU)

Score: -1

Dave Bautista

as Rhino in Spider-verse 3: Reborn (MCU)

Score: -2

Emma Stone

as Gwen Stacey in Spider-verse 3: Reborn (MCU)

Score: +1

Jenny Slate

as Otto Octavius (female) in Spider-verse 3: Reborn (MCU)

Score: -1

Keanu Reeves

as Sirius Black in Harry Potter

Score: -2

Tyler Posey

as Spencer in The Walking Dead Reboot

Score: +1

David Tennant

as The Stranger in The Walking Dead: Telltale Series

Score: +1

Rahul Kohli

as Omid in The Walking Dead: Telltale Series

Score: +2

Tika Sumpter

as Christa in The Walking Dead: Telltale Series

Score: +1

Jorge Lucas

as Chuck in The Walking Dead: Telltale Series

Score: +1

Nancy Cartwright

as Brenda St. John in The Walking Dead: Telltale Series

Score: +2

Andrew Scott

as Danny St. John in The Walking Dead: Telltale Series

Score: +1

Ian Anthony Dale

as Andy St. John in The Walking Dead: Telltale Series

Score: +1

Colin Ford

as Ben in The Walking Dead: Telltale Series

Score: +1

Tyler Hoechlin

as Mark in The Walking Dead: Telltale Series

Score: +1

Brian Hull

as Doug in The Walking Dead: Telltale Series

Score: +1

Jodelle Ferland

as Carley in The Walking Dead: Telltale Series

Score: +1

Graham McTavish

as Larry in The Walking Dead: Telltale Series

Score: +1

Katie McGrath

as Lilly in The Walking Dead: Telltale Series

Score: +2

Nicole Sullivan

as Katjaa in The Walking Dead: Telltale Series

Score: 0