Suggestions by @luanna255

Toni Mahfud

as Wolf in The Lunar Chronicles

Score: 0

Oscar Isaac

as Carl Romeo in So You Want to Be a Wizard

Score: +2

Eddie Cahill

as Carl Romeo in So You Want to Be a Wizard

Score: +2

Matt Bomer

as Tom Swale in So You Want to Be a Wizard

Score: +1

Henry Golding

as Tom Swale in So You Want to Be a Wizard

Score: +1

Emily Carey

as Sybill Vane in Oscar Wilde's The picture of Dorian Gray

Score: +2

Maggie Gyllenhaal

as Maude Delmont in American Crime Story: The People vs Roscoe "Fatty" Arbuckle

Score: +2

Gary Cooper

as Quincey Morris in Dracula 1931 (Recast)

Score: -3

John Wayne

as Quincey Morris in Dracula 1931 (Recast)

Score: -3

Conrad Veidt

as Abraham van Helsing in Dracula 1931 (Recast)

Score: -4

Leslie Howard

as Arthur Holmwood in Dracula 1931 (Recast)

Score: -3

Colin Clive

as John Seward in Dracula 1931 (Recast)

Score: -2

Maureen O'Sullivan

as Lucy Westenra in Dracula 1931 (Recast)

Score: -3

Madeleine Carroll

as Lucy Westenra in Dracula 1931 (Recast)

Score: -2

Anna Neagle

as Mina Murray in Dracula 1931 (Recast)

Score: -1

Merle Oberon

as Mina Murray in Dracula 1931 (Recast)

Score: -2

Bela Lugosi

as Count Dracula in Dracula 1931 (Recast)

Score: -5

Richard Madden

as The Lone Power in So You Want to Be a Wizard

Score: +2

Dan Stevens

as The Lone Power in So You Want to Be a Wizard

Score: +2

Domhnall Gleeson

as The Lone Power in So You Want to Be a Wizard

Score: +2