Suggestions by @lowkeycast

Shay Mitchell

as Lyrek in Charmed: Destined

Score: +1

Jennifer Rhodes

as Penny Halliwell in Charmed: Destined

Score: +1

Finola Hughes

as Patty Halliwell in Charmed: Destined

Score: +1

Shannen Doherty

as Prue Halliwell in Charmed: Destined

Score: +2

Kristen Stewart

as Bella Swan in Twilight

Score: -2

Shannon Purser

as Mary Jane Watson in Characters for future MCU movies

Score: +2

Kit Connor

as Hulkling in Characters for future MCU movies

Score: +4

Joe Locke

as Wiccano in Characters for future MCU movies

Score: -1

Joshua Bassett

as Wiccano in Characters for future MCU movies

Score: 0

Gigi Hadid

as Dina Caliente in Sims 4

Score: 0

Ross Lynch

as Travis Scott in Sims 4

Score: +4

Hailee Steinfeld

as Liberty Lee in Sims 4

Score: +8

Sydney Sweeney

as Summer Holiday in Sims 4

Score: +8

Madelaine Petsch

as Angela Pleasant in Sims 4

Score: +2

Holland Roden

as Lillith Pleasant in Sims 4

Score: -3

Kayla Sims

as Eliza Pancakes in Sims 4

Score: +6

Connor Swindells

as David Nelson in Heartstopper

Score: -2

Evan Ovenell

as Christian in Heartstopper

Score: +3

Ashwin Viswanath

as Sai in Heartstopper

Score: +4

Robbie Kay

as David Nelson in Heartstopper

Score: -4