Suggestions by @loserdream

Jessica Alexander

as Kaitlin Cooper in the O.C.-(2021 recast)

Score: +3

Clea DuVall

as Dot in The Wilds (90s)

Score: +3

Omar Epps

as Ivan in The Wilds (90s)

Score: +1

Andrea Navedo

as Martha in The Wilds (90s)

Score: +3

Elijah Wood

as Ian in The Wilds (90s)

Score: +2

Sara Gilbert

as Becca in The Wilds (90s)

Score: +4

Seth Rogen

as Bo in The Wilds (90s)

Score: +2

Aaliyah

as Rachel in The Wilds (90s)

Score: +4

Liv Tyler

as Leah in The Wilds (90s)

Score: +3

Natasha Lyonne

as Dot in The Wilds (90s)

Score: +2

Rachel True

as Rachel in The Wilds (90s)

Score: +3

Susan Sarandon

as Gretchen in The Wilds (90s)

Score: +1

Kelly Hu

as Linh/Jeanette in The Wilds (90s)

Score: +3

Erika Alexander

as Rachel in The Wilds (90s)

Score: -1

Macaulay Culkin

as Ian in The Wilds (90s)

Score: +1

Jonathan Taylor Thomas

as Quinn in The Wilds (90s)

Score: +2

Jason Segel

as DJ in The Wilds (90s)

Score: +1

Brittany Murphy

as Becca in The Wilds (90s)

Score: 0

Joseph Gordon-Levitt

as Henry in The Wilds (90s)

Score: +1

Freddie Prinze Jr.

as Seth in The Wilds (90s)

Score: 0