Suggestions by @loreguyt

Steve Buscemi

as Hero Uruk in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: +1

Adam Croasdell

as Torvin Stiffbeard in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: +1

Charlize Theron

as Berúthiel in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: +1

Eamon Farren

as Herumor in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: +1

Emma D'Arcy

as Morindiel (Lithaeriel's mother) in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: +1

Damson Idris

as Baranor in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: +1

Clive Standen

as Narmacil Minohtar in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: +1

Cengiz Coşkun

as Khamûl in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: +1

Christopher Lee

as Saruman in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: +1

Thorbjørn Harr

as Erkenbrand in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: +2

Thorbjørn Harr

as Erkenbrand in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: +1

Sophia Brown

as Yusara in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: -1

Lupita Nyong'o

as Yusara in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: +1

Cynthia Erivo

as Yusara in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: -2

Conan Stevens

as Golruk in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: +1

Will Smith

as Ratbag in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: 0

Jada Pinkett Smith

as Mudgal in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: -1

Kerry Washington

as Mudgal in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: -1

Tika Sumpter

as Mudgal in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: -1

Freema Agyeman

as Mudgal in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: +1