Suggestions by @lordpissedoffski

Jeremy Irons

as Adam Crowley in Nightmare Creatures

Eiza González

as Rachel in Nightmare Creatures

Nicholas Hoult

as Herbert Wallace in Nightmare Creatures

Eddie Redmayne

as Herbert Wallace in Nightmare Creatures

Elizabeth Gillies

as Nadia Franciscus in Nightmare Creatures

Rob Zombie

as Composer in Zombies Ate My Neighbors

Christopher Mintz-Plasse

as Zeke in Zombies Ate My Neighbors

Avan Jogia

as Jon Talbain in Darkstalkers

Tilda Swinton

as Queen of Hearts in American McGee's Alice

Willem Dafoe

as Hatter in American McGee's Alice

Melissa McCarthy

as The Duchess in American McGee's Alice

Elizabeth Olsen

as Elizabeth "Lizzie" Liddell in American McGee's Alice

Elizabeth Gillies

as Alice in American Mcgee's Alice

Elizabeth Gillies

as Alice in American McGee's Alice

Rosemary Harris

as Priscilla "Pris" Witless in American McGee's Alice

Kate Beckinsale

as Justine Florbelle in Amnesia: Justine

Ronny Yu

as Director in Nightmare Creatures