Suggestions by @lookslikeloe

David Dastmalchian

as Man-Bat in The Batman Trilogy

Score: +2

Emma Watson

as The Phantasm in The Batman Trilogy

Score: -1

Ross Lynch

as Firefly in The Batman Trilogy

Score: +3

Aaron Paul

as Black Mask in The Batman Trilogy

Score: +2

Harry Melling

as Calendar Man in The Batman Trilogy

Score: +2

Hayden Christensen

as Two-Face in The Batman Trilogy

Score: -1

Kyliegh Curran

as Barbara Gordon in The Batman Trilogy

Score: +4

Noah Jupe

as Robin (3) in The Batman Trilogy

Score: +2

Jay Lycurgo

as Robin (2) in The Batman Trilogy

Score: +1

Jackson Robert Scott

as Robin in The Batman Trilogy

Score: +1

Harry Melling

as Firefly in The Batman Trilogy

Score: -1

Pedro Pascal

as Deadshot in The Batman Trilogy

Score: +3

Mads Mikkelsen

as Thomas Wayne in The Batman Trilogy

Score: +2

Lars Mikkelsen

as Hugo Strange in The Batman Trilogy

Score: -1

Riz Ahmed

as Ra's al Ghul in The Batman Trilogy

Score: +2

Simu Liu

as Talon in The Batman Trilogy

Score: +2

Michael B. Jordan

as Talon in The Batman Trilogy

Score: +2

Lisa Kudrow

as Leslie Thompkins in The Batman Trilogy

Score: +2

Sally Field

as Leslie Thompkins in The Batman Trilogy

Score: +3

Emma Stone

as The Phantasm in The Batman Trilogy

Score: +2