Suggestions by @lookingglass

Rosa Salazar

as Samantha Heather Mackey in Bunny

Score: -6

Thomas Brodie-Sangster

as Jonah in Bunny

Score: -7

Sebastian de Souza

as Max in Bunny

Score: -7

Zendaya

as Victoria Fielding in Bunny

Score: -12

Sydney Sweeney

as Caroline Anderson in Bunny

Score: +6

Jacob Anderson

as Theodore in Alice

Score: -1

Sydney Sweeney

as Caged Mermaid in Alice

Score: +1

Tiffany Espensen

as Caged Butterfly in Alice

Score: +1

Stephan James

as Theobald in Alice

Score: +1

Shamier Anderson

as Theobald in Alice

Score: -1

Noomi Rapace

as Maze Monster in Alice

Score: +1

Ingrid Bolsø Berdal

as Maze Monster in Alice

Score: -1

Amanda Collin

as Maze Monster in Alice

Score: -1

Joseph Morgan

as Theodore in Alice

Score: -1

Ed Skrein

as Theodore in Alice

Score: -1

Brandon McKnight

as Theodore in Alice

Score: +1

Sydney Sweeney

as Dolly in Alice

Score: +1

Jessica Henwick

as Hattie in Alice

Score: +3

Toby Sebastian

as Cod in Alice

Score: +1

Tiffany Espensen

as Dolly in Alice

Score: -2