Suggestions by @lol97

Alexandra Breckenridge

as American Horror Story in Face Claims Sorted by TV Shows

Score: +2

Billy Eichner

as American Horror Story in Face Claims Sorted by TV Shows

Score: 0

Mare Winningham

as American Horror Story in Face Claims Sorted by TV Shows

Score: +1

Neil Patrick Harris

as American Horror Story in Face Claims Sorted by TV Shows

Score: +3

Stevie Nicks

as American Horror Story in Face Claims Sorted by TV Shows

Score: +2

Danny Huston

as American Horror Story in Face Claims Sorted by TV Shows

Score: +1

Patti LuPone

as American Horror Story in Face Claims Sorted by TV Shows

Score: +1

Ian McShane

as American Horror Story in Face Claims Sorted by TV Shows

Score: +1

Kate Mara

as American Horror Story in Face Claims Sorted by TV Shows

Score: +2

Leslie Grossman

as American Horror Story in Face Claims Sorted by TV Shows

Score: +1

Adina Porter

as American Horror Story in Face Claims Sorted by TV Shows

Score: +2

Alison Pill

as American Horror Story in Face Claims Sorted by TV Shows

Score: +1

Billie Lourd

as American Horror Story in Face Claims Sorted by TV Shows

Score: +3

André Holland

as American Horror Story in Face Claims Sorted by TV Shows

Score: +1

Cheyenne Jackson

as American Horror Story in Face Claims Sorted by TV Shows

Score: 0

Matt Bomer

as American Horror Story in Face Claims Sorted by TV Shows

Score: +5

Michael Chiklis

as American Horror Story in Face Claims Sorted by TV Shows

Score: +2

James Cromwell

as American Horror Story in Face Claims Sorted by TV Shows

Score: +1

Lizzie Brocheré

as American Horror Story in Face Claims Sorted by TV Shows

Score: +3

Joseph Fiennes

as American Horror Story in Face Claims Sorted by TV Shows

Score: +3