Suggestions by @lllaryn

Kristen Stewart

as silhouette in Rorschach

Score: +1

Jake McDorman

as nell Gardner/captain Metropolis in Rorschach

Score: +1

Laryn Hollywood Smith

as Director in Black Adam: The Return

Score: +1

Before Watchmen

as Comic Book Based Off in Rorschach

Score: +1

Billy Campbell

as James ford in ROCKETEER

Score: +2

Austin Butler

as Cliff Ford/The Rocketeer in ROCKETEER

Score: +2

Watchmen (2009) Fillm

as Comic Book Based Off in Rorschach

Score: -2

Laryn Hollywood Smith

as Director in Rorschach

Score: +1

Dave Bautista

as Destroyer Barbarian in Destroyer barbarian

Score: +2

Arnold Schwarzenegger

as King Conan in Destroyer barbarian

Score: +2

Sean Patrick Thomas

as Jefferson Pierce/black Lightning in DCEU

Score: +1

Jennifer Connelly

as Sarah in Labyrinth: the goblins heir

Score: +1

Hugh Dancy

as Toby in Labyrinth: the goblins heir

Score: +1

Jason Ritter

as Scarecrow in Wizard of Oz

Score: +1

Katie Crown

as Kaly in Heavenly

Score: +2

Cheyenne Jackson

as Hooded justice in Rorschach

Score: +3

Jason Ritter

as Scarecrow in Wizard of Oz

Score: +2

Ntare Guma Mbaho Mwine

as Gorilla grodd in DCEU

Score: +2

Billy Crudup

as Blue God in Rorschach

Score: +1

Stephen Hillenburg

as Director in SpongeBob & Patrick

Score: +1