Suggestions by @lizbxoxo
14 suggestions
Michelle Pfeiffer
as Gloria Rasputin in Bye Bye Birdie
Score: -1
Jane Lynch
as Mae Peterson in Bye Bye Birdie
Score: +1
Shawn Mendes
as Conrad Birdie in Bye Bye Birdie
Score: +2
Ricardo Hurtado
as Karl in Bye Bye Birdie Live!
Score: +2
Asher Angel
as Fred in Bye Bye Birdie Live!
Score: 0
Jade Pettyjohn
as Nancy in Bye Bye Birdie Live!
Score: +2
Joshua Bassett
as Hugo Peabody in Bye Bye Birdie Live!
Score: +4
John Stamos
as Charles Maude in Bye Bye Birdie Live!
Score: +2
Matthew Morrison
as Albert Peterson in Bye Bye Birdie Live!
Score: +4
Robert Pattinson
as Lord Barkis Bitten in The Corpse Bride
Score: +1
Lily Collins
as Victoria in The Corpse Bride
Score: 0
Kristine Froseth
as Emily in The Corpse Bride
Score: +1
Madeleine Arthur
as Emily in The Corpse Bride
Score: -3
Timothée Chalamet
as Victor in The Corpse Bride
Score: +2