Suggestions by @lisareads

Chace Crawford

as Tinker Grey in Rules of Civility

Score: 0

Blake Lively

as Kate Kontent in Rules of Civility

Score: -1

Hannah Brown

as Hannah Martin in Maybe in Another Life

Score: -6

Troian Bellisario

as Kenna Rowan in Reminders Of Him

Score: -5

Brooklyn Decker

as Cassandra in Local Woman Missing

Score: +2

Yvonne Strahovski

as Kate in Local Woman Missing

Score: +3

Liam Hemsworth

as Billy in All Good People Here

Score: -2

Miles Teller

as Pete in All Good People Here

Score: +4

Chris Pine

as Luke in All Good People Here

Score: +1

January Jones

as Krissy in All Good People Here

Score: -1