Suggestions by @lexiodonnell

Nicolas Cage

as Archer Graff in Weapons (2005)

Score: +5

Matthew Lilard

as Dave in Five Nights at Freddy's:The Week Before

Score: +1

Skeet Ulrich

as Charlie Swan in Twilight animated

Score: +1

Emma Tammi

as Director in Fnaf tv series

Score: +1

Lucas Grant

as Garrett in Fnaf tv series

Score: +1

Miriam Spumpkin

as Young Vanessa in Fnaf tv series

Score: +2

Audrey Lynn-Marie

as Charlie Emily in Fnaf tv series

Score: +2

Jophielle Love

as Susie in Fnaf tv series

Score: +1

Liam Hendrix

as Gabriel in Fnaf tv series

Score: +1

David Huston

as Jeremy in Fnaf tv series

Score: +1

Asher Colton Spence

as Fritz in Fnaf tv series

Score: +1

Grant Feely

as Cassidy in Fnaf tv series

Score: +1

Billy Burke

as Clay Burke in Fnaf tv series

Score: +1

Skeet Ulrich

as Henry Emily in Fnaf tv series

Score: +1

Matthew Lillard

as William Afton in Fnaf tv series

Score: +2

Ken Kaneki

as Killers in Who Should Join Dead By Daylight?

Score: +4

Piper Rubio

as Cream the rabbit in Sonic movie 4

Score: +1

Cillian Murphy

as Henry Stein in Bendy and the ink machine movie

Score: +1

J.K. Simmons

as Joey Drew in Bendy and the ink machine movie

Score: +1

Tom Kenny

as Bendy in Bendy and the ink machine movie

Score: +1