Suggestions by @lennoxtanderson

Brian Eno

as Jareth the Goblin King in Labyrinth

Score: -6

David Bowie

as Jimmy Carter in Peanut One

Score: -1

Jimmy Carter

as Ellen Claremont in Red, White & Royal Blue

Score: -23

Jimmy Carter

as The President of the United States in Elite Cinematic Universe

Score: -1

Ginuwine

as Donna Meagle in Parks and Recreation

Score: -1

Barack Obama

as Interviewer in Jaws Recasted

Score: +1

Mrs. William G. Henkels

as Mrs. Kintner in Jaws Recasted

Score: +1

Chrissie Cotterill

as Chrissie Watkins in Jaws Recasted

Score: 0

Donald Trump

as Deputy Hendricks in Jaws Recasted

Score: +1

Tim Meadows

as Meadows in Jaws Recasted

Score: +1

Nic Montemayor

as Mayor Larry Vaughn in Jaws Recasted

Score: +1

Marilyn Villamayor

as Mayor Larry Vaughn in Jaws Recasted

Score: -1

Carlos Sotto Mayor

as Mayor Larry Vaughn in Jaws Recasted

Score: -1

Elliot Page

as Ellen Brody in Jaws Recasted

Score: 0

Paul Rudd

as Matt Hooper in Jaws Recasted

Score: +1

Ian McShane

as Quint in Jaws Recasted

Score: +1

Mark Ruffalo

as Cheif Martin Brody in Jaws Recasted

Score: +1

Wattanasom Meksuwan

as Mrs. Mason in Harry Potter (HBO Max Series)

Score: -5

Korn Khunatipapisiri

as Mr. Mason in Harry Potter (HBO Max Series)

Score: 0

Alexandra Daddario

as Madame Pomfrey in Harry Potter (HBO Max Series)

Score: +1