Suggestions by @lendanielblones

James Marsden

as Richard White in The Return of Superman

Score: +1

Evan Peters

as Jimmy Olsen in The Return of Superman

Score: +1

Pedro Pascal

as Marcos Sosas in The Return of Superman

Score: +1

Kevin Spacey

as Lex Luthor in The Return of Superman

Score: 0

Parker Posey

as Lois Lane in The Return of Superman

Score: +1

Brandon Routh

as Superman in The Return of Superman

Score: +2

Lucas Till

as Alexander Summers in Summers

Score: +1

Chris Pine

as Scott Summers in Summers

Score: -1