Suggestions by @leahwilson

Terry Crews

as Hephaestus in Elevator to Tartarus

Score: +2

Issa Rae

as Medusa in Elevator to Tartarus

Score: +1

Kristen Wiig

as Hera in Elevator to Tartarus

Score: +1

Rob Mac

as Poseidon in Elevator to Tartarus

Score: +1

Chris Hemsworth

as Zeus in Elevator to Tartarus

Score: +1

Zach Galifianakis

as Dionysus in Elevator to Tartarus

Score: +1

Sigourney Weaver

as Metis in Elevator to Tartarus

Score: +1

Tina Fey

as Athena in Elevator to Tartarus

Score: +1

J.K. Simmons

as Kronus in Elevator to Tartarus

Score: +1

Idris Elba

as Erebus in Elevator to Tartarus

Score: +1

Andy Samberg

as Apollo in Elevator to Tartarus

Score: +1

Jason Mantzoukas

as Chiron in Elevator to Tartarus

Score: +1

Jordan Peele

as Remus in Elevator to Tartarus

Score: +1

Lisa Edelstein

as Demeter in Elevator to Tartarus

Score: +1

Jennifer Coolidge

as Aphrodite in Elevator to Tartarus

Score: +1

Felicia Day

as Artemis in Elevator to Tartarus

Score: +1

Gianmarco Soresi

as Eros in Elevator to Tartarus

Score: +1

Tom Hiddleston

as Thanatos in Elevator to Tartarus

Score: +1

Hannah Simone

as Persephone in Elevator to Tartarus

Score: +1

Keegan-Michael Key

as Romulus in Elevator to Tartarus

Score: +1