Suggestions by @ladyfrost

Jesse Williams

as Tarquin in ACOTAR

Score: +1

Timothée Chalamet

as Rhysand in ACOTAR

Score: -2

Theo James

as Rhysand in ACOTAR

Score: -2

Lou Ferrigno Jr.

as Rhysand in ACOTAR

Score: -2

Brant Daugherty

as Rhysand in ACOTAR

Score: -2

Charles Melton

as Rhysand in ACOTAR

Score: -2

Miles Teller

as Rhysand in ACOTAR

Score: -2

Dacre Montgomery

as Rhysand in ACOTAR

Score: -2

Ben Barnes

as Rhysand in ACOTAR

Score: -2

Jake Abel

as Tamlin in ACOTAR

Score: +1

Bradley James

as Tamlin in ACOTAR

Score: +1

Kellan Lutz

as Tamlin in ACOTAR

Score: +1

George MacKay

as Tamlin in ACOTAR

Score: +1

Jamie Campbell Bower

as Tamlin in ACOTAR

Score: +1

Will Poulter

as Tamlin in ACOTAR

Score: +1

Garrett Hedlund

as Tamlin in ACOTAR

Score: +1

Sam Claflin

as Tamlin in ACOTAR

Score: +2

Lucas Till

as Tamlin in ACOTAR

Score: +1

Alexander Skarsgård

as Tamlin in ACOTAR

Score: -1

Octavia Spencer

as Alis in ACOTAR

Score: +1