Suggestions by @kyleedunn
167 suggestions
Samantha O’Donnell
as Elphaba in Wicked (2021)
Score: -3
Vera Farmiga
as Bill in Mamma Mia!
Score: 0
Billy Eichner
as Harry in Mamma Mia!
Score: +1
Jane Fonda
as Tanya in Mamma Mia!
Score: +1
John Stamos
as Sam in Mamma Mia!
Score: +1
Matthew Morrison
as Albert Peterson in Bye Bye Birdie
Score: +1
Thomas Sanders
as Hugo Peabody in Bye Bye Birdie Live!
Score: +1
Carol Burnett
as Mae Peterson in Bye Bye Birdie Live!
Score: +3
Robert Manion
as Bobby Mills in A Chorus Line Live!
Score: +4
Nick Adams
as Greg Gardner in A Chorus Line Live!
Score: +2
Tom Holland
as Mark Anthony in A Chorus Line Live!
Score: +1
Zendaya
as Judy Turner in A Chorus Line Live!
Score: +1
Eloise Kropp
as Bebe Benzenheimer in A Chorus Line Live!
Score: 0
Ryan McCartan
as Al DeLuca in A Chorus Line Live!
Score: +3
John Stamos
as Zach in A Chorus Line Live!
Score: +5
Kate Hudson
as Cassie Ferguson in A Chorus Line Live!
Score: +2
Eva Noblezada
as Cassie Ferguson in A Chorus Line Live!
Score: -3
Anthony Ramos
as Paul San Marco in A Chorus Line Live!
Score: +3
Ana Villafañe
as Diana Morales in A Chorus Line Live!
Score: +2
Dove Cameron
as Chloe in Bratz Reeboot(story removed)
Score: -1