Suggestions by @kylecooke

Madelaine Petsch

as Brittany Gibson in The Gibson Family Christmas

Score: -1

Leighton Meester

as Megan Gibson-McNulty in The Gibson Family Christmas

Score: -1

Jessica Rothe

as Candice Gibson in The Gibson Family Christmas

Score: -1

Brock Brenner

as Dallas McNulty in The Gibson Family Christmas

Score: +1

Michael Cera

as Simon Gibson in The Gibson Family Christmas

Score: +1

Jaeden Martell

as Sam Gibson in The Gibson Family Christmas

Score: +1

Laura Marano

as Melanie Morris in The Gibson Family Christmas

Score: -2

Katherine McNamara

as Stella Roberts in The Gibson Family Christmas

Score: -1

Bailee Madison

as Leslie Gibson in The Gibson Family Christmas

Score: -1

Grant Gustin

as Ethan Gibson in The Gibson Family Christmas

Score: -1

Yan-Kay Crystal Lowe

as Angela Hill in The Gibson Family Christmas

Score: +1

Liam Hemsworth

as Jason Morris in The Gibson Family Christmas

Score: -1

Josh Hutcherson

as Darren Briggs in The Gibson Family Christmas

Score: +1

Tara Reid

as Tara Abbott in The Gibson Family Christmas

Score: +1

George Clooney

as Arthur Gibson in The Gibson Family Christmas

Score: -1

Taylor Kitsch

as Gary McNulty in The Gibson Family Christmas

Score: -1

Gregory Smith

as Christian Brewer in The Gibson Family Christmas

Score: +1

Rachel Brosnahan

as Kristen Gibson-Caldwell in The Gibson Family Christmas

Score: -1

George Newbern

as Jake Morris in The Gibson Family Christmas

Score: -1

Alex Zamm

as Director in The Gibson Family Christmas

Score: +1