Suggestions by @kylebaird

Kate Mara

as Ethel Cain in Preacher’s Daughter

Score: +6

Ethan Slater

as Hickory in THE WONDERFUL WIZARD OF OZ (after "Wicked")

Score: +2

Jonathan Bailey

as Hunk in THE WONDERFUL WIZARD OF OZ (after "Wicked")

Score: +2

Noah Jupe

as Holden Caulfield in The Catcher in the Rye

Score: 0

Nicole Kidman

as Chris MacNeil in The Exorcist (2023 50th Anniversary Remake)

Score: +3

Nicole Kidman

as Chris MacNeil in The Exorcist (1983)

Score: +1

Froylan Gutierrez

as Dorothy in Wicked (Genderswap)

Score: +1

Isaac Powell

as Orpheus in Hadestown Movie

Score: +1

Una Stubbs

as Miss bat in The worst witch

Score: +2

Jenn Colella

as Miss drill in The worst witch

Score: +1

Ellen Burstyn

as Miss Cackle in The worst witch

Score: +1

Elaine Haro

as Enid Nightshade in The worst witch

Score: +1

Michelle Gomez

as Miss hardbroom in The worst witch

Score: +3

Hattie Gotobed

as Maud Moonshine in The worst witch

Score: +1

Sienna Nash

as Mildred Hubble in The worst witch

Score: +1

Josh Dylan

as Aurora in Disney Genderbent

Score: +1

Jesús Castro

as Esmeralda in Disney Genderbent

Score: +1

Lance Lim

as Mulan in Disney Genderbent

Score: +2