Suggestions by @knight_ofgotham

Amy Acker

as Pieck Finger in Attack on Titan (Shingeki no Kyojin) (2000s)

Score: +1

Jim Caviezel

as Captain Levi Ackerman in Attack on Titan (Shingeki no Kyojin) (2000s)

Score: +1

Donald Sutherland

as Batman in 80's Justice League fancast (please read synopsis)

Score: +2

Rachel Bilson

as Zatanna Zatara in Batman/Spider-Man

Score: +1

Grace Caroline Currey

as Mary Jane Watson in Batman/Spider-Man

Score: +1

Daniel Sharman

as Richard Fisk in Batman/Spider-Man

Score: +1

Ian McShane

as Carmine Falcone in Batman/Spider-Man

Score: +1

Vince Vaughn

as Wilson Fisk in Batman/Spider-Man

Score: +1

Michael Chiklis

as Wilson Fisk in Batman/Spider-Man

Score: -1

Daniel Gillies

as Bruce Wayne in Batman/Spider-Man

Score: +1

Michael Fassbender

as Bruce Wayne in Batman/Spider-Man

Score: -1

Cameron Cuffe

as Peter Parker in Batman/Spider-Man

Score: +1

Jim Caviezel

as Bruce Wayne in Batman/Spider-Man

Score: +1

Amy Acker

as Zatanna Zatara Wayne in Hellbat

Score: +1

Brenton Thwaites

as Peter Parker in MCU Reboot Fancast

Score: 0

Emilia Clarke

as Zatanna Zatara in Superman: New Krypton

Score: +1

Jenna Coleman

as Huntress in Every Batman Character

Score: +2

Ben Barnes

as Bruce Wayne/Batman in Batman: Gotham by Gaslight (2007)

Score: +1

Jane Levy

as Mary Jane Watson in Amazing Spider Man 3 (2023)

Score: +1

Erik Oleson

as Director in Batman: Gotham By Gaslight Season 1

Score: +1